We're doing this shit again: desert island albums

[Exy]

Yeah I know we've already had this thread. But you know what, I enjoyed it so damn much that I want to have the whole conversation all over again. The rules are: if you posted in the old thread, don't look at your post. I'm interested in seeing if people's choices will change over time.

So anyway, the situation is, you're going on a three hour tour and you bring along your new iPod Solar which can be recharged with nothing but sunlight, but as a consequence of its eco-friendly solar cells and guilt-free non-heavy-metal components, it can only hold five albums. When you're marooned on that island with Mary-Ann and Ginger and the Skipper, what do you wish were on your mp3 player, since it's all you'll be able to listen to?

My choices:
The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady by Charles Mingus
A Love Supreme by John Coltrane
Graceland by Paul Simon
Doolittle by the Pixies
The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill

What are yours?

[Zuul]

Bah. This was really difficult. Also my choices look completely schizoid. Good call on Lauryn Hill's solo album, Exy.

Graceland by Paul Simon
This Delicate Thing We've Made by Darren Hayes
Black Holes and Revelations by Muse
The White Album by the Beatles
The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill

[Inner Stickler]

Umm, you are all going to make fun of me.

The Fame Monster by Lady Gaga
Broken Bride by Ludo
supersunnyspeedgraphic by Ben Folds
Dresden Dolls by the Dresden Dolls
You're Awful, I Love You also by Ludo

[Zuul]

I'd never make fun of you. You've just reminded me that one of the things I need to replace from the fire is my Dresden Dolls album!

[What Exit?]

My 5:
Wish You Were Here by Pink Floyd
Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd
The White Album By The Beatles
Zep 4 by Led Zeppelin
Yes Songs by Yes

[Myrnalene]

Cargo by Men at Work
Resident Alien by Spacehog
Magical Mystery Tour by the Beatles
So by Peter Gabriel
Weezer's Blue Album

[jali]

What's Going On - Marvin Gaye
A Night at The Opera - Queen
The Barbra Streisand Album - Barbra Streisand
Hard Knock Life - Jay Z
Ella Fitzgerald Sings The Duke Ellington Songbook - Ella Fitzgerald

[What Exit?]

So far I want to be stuck on the Island with Jali. I like her 5 the best after my own.

[jali]

So far I want to be stuck on the Island with Jali. I like her 5 the best after my own.

I'd love to share an island with you!

[Taumpy]

Huh. When I started this thread before you scolded me for only allowing five albums, Exy. And with this thread I'm going to agree. Five is way too few!

Vespertine - Björk
The Dreaming - Kate Bush
The Crossing - Big Country
Skylarking - XTC
The Planet's Suite - Gustav Holst (the recording isn't particularly important, though the one I have is Eugene Ormandy)

And ftr, I'd be content to be stuck on any of your islands. Mellos have decent music taste.

[Panther Squad]

Hmm, I'd say...
Janet Jackson Control
Blossom Dearie, Once Upon a Summertime
Sade, Diamond Life
Neneh Cherry, Raw Like Sushi
The B-52's, s/t

Or at least, that's what I'd say right now at this second.

[Sarahfeena]

Nevermind, Nirvana
Ten, Pearl Jam
Original Cast Recording of Les Miserables
The Concert in the Park, Paul Simon
The While Album, The Beatles

[Orual]

Dirt - Alice in Chains
Back in Black - AC/DC
Kid A - Radiohead
The Soundtrack to Amélie
Elephant - The White Stripes

[What Exit?]

Nevermind, Nirvana
Ten, Pearl Jam
Original Cast Recording of Les Miserables
The Concert in the Park, Paul Simon
The While Album, The Beatles

Sarah, I was at the Concert in the Park. I took the ferry up and met my fiancée (now wife) down in the finacial district and we headed up. We couldn't see the stage from where we ended up but it was still great. We ate a late dinner afterwards somewhere near Central Park. You know what is odd, we do not own the album.

Also I notice the White Album is doing very well so far.

[ivan astikov]

Unknown Pleasures - Joy Division
Forever Changes - Love
An American Prayer - Jim Morrison And The Doors
What's Going On? - Marvin Gaye
Scott2 - Scott Walker

[Sarahfeena]

Sarah, I was at the Concert in the Park. I took the ferry up and met my fiancée (now wife) down in the finacial district and we headed up. We couldn't see the stage from where we ended up but it was still great. We ate a late dinner afterwards somewhere near Central Park. You know what is odd, we do not own the album.

Also I notice the White Album is doing very well so far.

Jim, that is so cool that you were at that concert. I highly HIGHLY recommend the album. It's beautifully produced...the best live album I think I've heard. And it's got an amazing mix of songs on it. Truly great.