Printable View
In which we determine through an incontrovertibly objective scientific process what the absolute best kind of pie is:
1a) Apple
1b) Peach
2a) Blueberry
2b) Cherry
3a) Strawberry
3b) Strawberry-Rhubarb
4a) Raspberry
4b) Blackberry
5a) Lemon meringue
5b) Key lime
6a) Banana cream
6b) Coconut cream
7a) Sweet potato
7b) Pumpkin
8a) Pecan
8b) Mince
1a) Apple
2b) Cherry - this one was hard
3a) Strawberry
4a) Raspberry
5b) Key lime
6a) Banana cream
7b) Pumpkin
8a) Pecan
fruit
ok but really
1a) Apple
2a) Blueberry
3a) Strawberry
4b) Blackberry
5a) Lemon meringue
6a) Banana cream
7a) Sweet potato
8a) Pecan
1a) Apple (this one was hard)
2b) Cherry
3a) Strawberry
4b) Blackberry
5b) Key lime
6a) Banana cream
7a) Sweet potato
8b) Mince (another hard one, this time because I care for neither.
I will attempt to process this despite the glaring lack of chocolate, grasshopper, chicken pot, meat, and beef pies. But I'll assume this is a fruit-based dessert battle and you've just chosen to marginalize the rest of us who may enjoy a different type of pie more by forcing us to form a specialized minority of pie battle.
1b) Peach
2a) Blueberry
3b) Strawberry-Rhubarb
4a) Raspberry
5b) Key lime
6a) Banana cream
7b) Pumpkin
8b) Mince
A slice of good pecan pie is a mini-orgasm on a plate. Mince cannot compete.Quote:
Originally posted by Exy
Panther, yes, it was a strictly sweet pie battle. And I was going to do French silk as a choice but I couldn't think of another similar pie for its first match-up. Sorry!
So you're telling me that you're asking us appreciators of fine sweet pies to educate you because otherwise you can't be bothered to discover the fine options we enjoy daily. I am appalled at your pie behavior!Quote:
Originally posted by Exy
Well if you can come up with another 16 pies to match up against these we can then eventually battle them in one final Grand Pie Guignol.Quote:
Originally posted by Panther Squad
1a) Apple
2a) Blueberry
3b) Strawberry-Rhubarb
4a) Raspberry
5b) Key lime
6a) Banana cream
7b) Pumpkin
8a) Pecan
1a) Apple
2a) Blueberry
3b) Strawberry-Rhubarb
4a) Raspberry
5b) Key lime
6a) Banana cream
7b) Pumpkin
8b) Mince
1b) Peach
2b) Cherry
3a) Strawberry
4a) Raspberry
5b) Key lime
6a) Banana cream
7b) Pumpkin
8a) Pecan
1a) Apple
2b) Cherry
3a) Strawberry
4b) Blackberry
5b) Key lime
6a) Banana cream
7b) Pumpkin
8b) Mince
I voted for mince but really they can both diaf.
1a) Apple
2a) Blueberry
3a) Strawberry
4b) Blackberry
5b) Key lime
6b) Coconut cream
7b) Pumpkin
8a) Pecan
1b) Peach
2b) Cherry
3b) Strawberry-Rhubarb
4a) Raspberry
5b) Key lime
6b) Coconut cream
7b) Pumpkin
8a) Pecan
1a) Apple
2a) Blueberry
3b) Strawberry-Rhubarb
4b) Blackberry
5b) Key lime
6a) Banana cream
7b) Pumpkin
8b) Mince
And now round 2! Since it's been a couple days since anyone else has voted.
1a) Apple
1b) Blueberry
2a) Strawberry
2b) Raspberry
3a) Key Lime (this one won in a landslide!)
3b) Banana cream
4a) Pumpkin
4b) Pecan
1a) Apple
2b) Raspberry
3b) Banana cream
4a) Pumpkin
1a) Apple
2b) Raspberry
3a) Key Lime
4a) Pumpkin
1a) Apple
2b) Raspberry
3a) Key Lime
4a) Pumpkin
Damn, how can Cherry be eliminated so soon? :fist:
1a) Apple
2a) Strawberry
3a) Key Lime (this one won in a landslide!)
4b) Pecan
The board clearly has something agaisnt quintessential stripper-songs.Quote:
Originally posted by Sarahfeena
1a) Apple
2b) Raspberry (I've never actually seen one of these, but I approve of the concept.)
3a) Key Lime
4b) Pecan
I paired the pies in such a way as to guarantee my preferred outcome. I'm sure cherry would beat out mince and lemon meringue but really, what could beat blueberry? Aside, of course, from apple.Quote:
Originally posted by Sarahfeena
Also, seriously, if people keep voting pecan over pumpkin I'm gonna have to cut a bitch.
I knew this fucking thing was rigged.
I'm late to the game. Cherry is the shiznitz, but we might as well continue on to determine the second best pie.
1b) Blueberry
2a) Strawberry
3a) Key Lime (this one won in a landslide!)
4b) Pecan
BTW, around my place the rasberries are ripe, but the blueberries are not yet ripe.
1a) Apple
2b) Raspberry
3b) Banana cream
4a) Pumpkin
I don't like pumpkin pie. I guess the only way to guarantee that it is off the list is to give it to someone who like pumpkin pie . . . PUMPKIN PIE IN THE FACE TO EXY!Quote:
Originally posted by Exy
(Hey, you said it was a pie battle.)
1a) Apple
2a) Strawberry
3b) Banana cream
4a) Pumpkin (this is a sweet potato pie, but spelled differently here)
Pumpkin pie is gross, and I believe I already made my feelings about pecan clear.Quote:
Originally posted by Exy
1a) Apple
2a) Strawberry
3a) Key Lime
4a) Pumpkin
Round 3!
1a) Apple
1b) Raspberry
2a) Key lime
2b) Pumpkin
1a) Apple
2b) Pumpkin
Raspberry
Key lime
That was easy. I'm bitter that pecan has lost its place in contention, though.
1b) Raspberry
2a) Key lime
This is hard now. :(
Apple
(gets out the darts)
Pumpkin
1b) Raspberry
2a) Key lime
Rasberry
Key Lime
1a) Apple
2b) Pumpkin
SOMEONE NEEDS TO SHOW ME A RECIPE/PICTURE OF RASPBERRY PIE BECAUSE I DO NOT BELIEVE IT EXISTS.
Late to this party (and can't believe people would have Strawberry pie without rhubarb in it).
1) Apple
2) Key Lime
I love raspberries much more than apples, but pie is not the best way to present them.
1a) Apple
2b) Pumpkin
1a) Apple
2a) Key Lime
http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b2...Riw4QMwv4c.jpgQuote:
Originally posted by Orual
Uh, I forgot about this.
Final round:
1. Apple
2. Key lime
1. Apple
2. Key lime
1. Apple.
1. http://spillitsister.files.wordpress...apple_pie1.jpg
I want apple pie RIGHT NOW.
2. Key Lime