The non-fruit, sweet and savory pie battle!

Since the other pie battle was not included we are creating a separate, safe space environment for enjoyers of other fine pies that may not include fruit products.

1a) chicken pot pie
1b) cottage pie

2a) custard pie
2b) cream pie

3a) shoofly pie
3b) chess pie

4a) pork pie
4b) steak and kidney pie

5a) french silk pie*
5b) chocolate cream pie*

6a) peanut butter pie
6b) oreo cookie pie

Original list
1a) chicken pot pie
1b) cottage pie
2a) custard pie
2b) cream pie
3a) shoofly pie
3b) grasshopper pie
4a) pork pie
4b) steak and kidney pie
5a) french silk pie*
5b) chocolate cream pie*
6a) grasshoper pie
6b) lemon meringue pie
7a) peanut butter pie
7b) oreo cookie pie
8a) custard pie
8b) chess pie

* There's contention as to whether they are the same pies or they differ. Regardless, Mello, it is left to you to decide which pie, for differences in taste, perceived presentation, or preferred terminology, survives.

1a) chicken pot pie
2a) custard pie
3b) grasshopper pie
4a) pork pie
5b) chocolate cream pie*
6b) lemon meringue pie - don't wanna vote for grasshopper twice. :)
7b) oreo cookie pie

8- pass

I already did lemon meringue, and I did the two most popular cream pies. THREAD IS A FAILURE.

CHANGE IN PLANS

Due to my drunkeness and Tom's inability to edit we've needed to rearrange things. THANK YOU FOR YOUR INPUT EXY. Your discrimation and harsh words will be stored away in my heart for whenever I need the fuel to justify that i'm better than the rest of the world and/or any excuse to sing along to Mary J Blige's 90's albums because she just gets me

1a) chicken pot pie
1b) cottage pie

2a) custard pie
2b) cream pie

3a) shoofly pie
3b) chess pie

4a) pork pie
4b) steak and kidney pie

5a) french silk pie*
5b) chocolate cream pie*

7a) peanut butter pie
7b) oreo cookie pie

* There's contention as to whether they are the same pies or they differ. Regardless, Mello, it is left to you to decide which pie, for differences in taste, perceived presentation, or preferred terminology, survives.

DBL PST

Okay but if these are going to go up against the SUCCESSFUL pie battle that I started you need 16 total. See there have to be a number of pies equal to a power of 2. Like how the NCAA basketball tournament has 64 teams.

Quote:

---

Originally posted by Panther Squad

Tom's inability to edit

---

Don't blame me, drunky. :p

Quote:

---

Originally posted by Exy

Okay but if these are going to go up against the SUCCESSFUL pie battle that I started you need 16 total. See there have to be a number of pies equal to a power of 2. Like how the NCAA basketball tournament has 64 teams.

---

for future reference, I will basically not understand any sports references that involve like, the leagues or whatever they are. They mean nothing to me.

Also, this isn't about YOUR PIE BATTLE. It's about pie safe space!

Look I don't know anything about sports, I just know things about powers of two.

LOOK YOU NEED SIXTEEN PIES FOR THIS TO WORK JUST TAKE MY WORD FOR IT.

It's possible to do it with 14. Panther would just have to determine a seeding and then set up bye rounds for the top seeded pies. :)


/sports reference

SOMEONE NEEDS TO PUT THIS IN TOP MODEL TERMINOLOGY FOR ME, now I just keep thinking of sports and my thoughts refuse to budge further on the subject.

I'm afraid to vote, everyone is yelling.

There's also only 12, Exy. I just forgot to change the numbers so IN YOUR FACE

Okay look: you can't be bad at both math and sports, right?

To have one winner, it has to have competed with one other pie. So the second-to-last round has two. Those two each had to fight another pie. So four. Those four all had to fight another pie -- therefore 8. Those 8 had to fight another pie each, making 16.

You have twelve pies, meaning two rounds from now you'll have three -- one pie without an opponent. That's like if uh I've never watched Top Model but I mean imagine how horrible the world would be if there were three Tyras, that's how bad it would be.

Quote:

---

Originally posted by Panther Squad

There's also only 12, Exy. I just forgot to change the numbers so IN YOUR FACE

---

That was Tom who brought up 14, not me.

Quote:

---

Originally posted by Exy

Okay look: you can't be bad at both math and sports, right?

To have one winner, it has to have competed with one other pie. So the second-to-last round has two. Those two each had to fight another pie. So four. Those four all had to fight another pie -- therefore 8. Those 8 had to fight another pie each, making 16.

You have twelve pies, meaning two rounds from now you'll have three -- one pie without an opponent. That's like if uh I've never watched Top Model but I mean imagine how horrible the world would be if there were three Tyras, that's how bad it would be.

---

There could be twenty Tyras and there would still. only be. one. tyra banks. ...according to any of those Tyras you ask. Besides the other panelists are like Tyra's bobbling heads extended like some creepy Hindu goddess who rules over fantastic pointless things you can't turn away from.

Quote:

---

Originally posted by Exy

That was Tom who brought up 14, not me.

---

Selective editing is part of the Top Model experience.

1b) cottage pie


2b) cream pie

3a) shoofly pie


4a) pork pie


5a) french silk pie*


7a) peanut butter pie


Look, oreo is gross.

1a) chicken pot pie

2a) custard pie

3a) shoofly pie {Blech but other is worse}

4a) pork pie

5b) chocolate cream pie*

6b) oreo cookie pie