+ Reply to thread
Results 1 to 6 of 6

Thread: Dehydration Injuries and Student Athletes

  1. #1
    Curmudgeon OtakuLoki's avatar
    Registered
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Rochester, NY
    Posts
    2,836

    Default Dehydration Injuries and Student Athletes

    This is sparked by the recent news of the McMinnville High School Football team's experience with rhabdomyolysis in the wake of an intense pre-season workout/training camp. In short, 24 members of the team had to seek emergency medical attention for pain and other symptoms. 13 of that number were admitted for treatment, with three of the students requiring emergency surgery to treat compartment syndrome.

    Story here. Wiki articles for rhabdomyolysis and compartment syndrome linked as well.

    There is all sorts of FUBAR in this story, including concerns that the student athletes are reported to have been encouraged to consume a muscle building shake, which if that's the case, would have the effect of making the physiological complications of the rhabdomyolysis more extreme: overloading and possibly damaging the kidneys with an excess of protein in the bloodstream. The full report on that will have will have to wait until such time as the more sensitive tests that health officials have already ordered come back.

    What's damning, in my eyes, is that there's some accusations of serious misjudgment of heat injury potential. A portion of the workout took place in an enclosed wrestling room, without air conditioning. At least one parent has told The Oregonian that
    ...players have told him they were not allowed to drink water until they completed the exercises.

    The doctor who has taken the lead for treating the afflicted team members, and who doubles as the team's physician is also questioning the wisdom of this workout:
    Winkler, who doubles as the football team's physician, also questioned the wisdom of the workouts.

    Players told him "they were working out for more than 20 minutes in an enclosed room in 115-degree heat," Winkler said. "That seems pretty intense to me. From a medical point of view, I would not allow anyone to exercise at temperatures over 100."
    The school is admitting that water availability may be an issue - i.e. that there would be limited means for the athletes to get physical access to water, which is bad enough. But if the claim that the coach was denying the athletes water can be substantiated, I think we're into what should be at the very least considered demonstrated incompetence. Heat stroke is a very real concern, and kills enough people each year. Playing stupid 'character building' games with water availability should be just cause for firing anyone from a position as coach, IMNSHO. The fact that the NYT reports that heat and dehydration are risk factors for the condition that the athletes did suffer only makes me angrier.

    Now, in the real world, I'm not about to start buying into the idea that no one should exercise at temperatures above 100 F. That seems incredibly stupid to me, those temperatures do happen, and people have worked pretty strenuously in them through the ages. What I'd like to see, with that permission, however, is some recognition that it's a potentially dangerous temperature regime, and that ready access to water needs to be available, and that at the first signs of heat stress, people should be offered the chance to take breaks. i.e. do it in a sensible manner, not trying to act like you or the people you're supervising are some kind of machines that ignore the temperature around them.

    There are enough damaging things done in the name of high school sports that we don't need to allow or encourage coaches to ignore health concerns out of some macho bullshit.

  2. #2
    The Queen Zuul's avatar
    Registered
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Wisconsin
    Posts
    9,908

    Default

    I thought we all understood the importance of hydration at this point? Dehydrating your athletes is not going to improve their performance and any moron who's ever seen a commercial for the million and one sports drinks out there should have caught on that, yeah, drinking during exercise is kind of a big deal. If water simply wasn't readily available, that's boneheaded, but if it was actively denied them that goes into a whole new level of "what the fuck?"

    As for this:

    "That seems pretty intense to me. From a medical point of view, I would not allow anyone to exercise at temperatures over 100."
    This is actually common medical advice and while it's probably good from a CYA point of view, I think it's a little extreme. We did not all lock ourselves indoors and hide under the air conditioning vent when I lived in Nevada. We ran. We jogged. We did yard work. I saw people doing the exact same things on the streets of New Orleans in the afternoon sun when it was probably 105 degrees and 90% humidity. You need to be aware, hydrated and not push yourself if you're in heat and it sounds like the coach was irresponsible at best, but a healthy human being can be active when it's over a hundred degrees.
    So now they are just dirt-covered English people in fur pelts with credit cards.

  3. #3
    A Groupie Marsilia's avatar
    Registered
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Mississippi
    Posts
    1,988

    Default

    What bothers me most about this is that it isn't the first time student athletes have been injured by heat and dehydration. I don't have cites, but I've heard about at least one other case where the coach was later charged with something for keeping his football team out in 100+ degree heat, and local news down here generally has at least one story a year (usually in August/September) about heat safety and sports.
    So, I'll whisper in the dark, hoping you'll hear me.

  4. #4
    Curmudgeon OtakuLoki's avatar
    Registered
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Rochester, NY
    Posts
    2,836

    Default

    Exactly, it's not a newly discovered hazard. It's disgustingly common. And the coach's claim:
    I didn't know it could get that hot in Oregon.
    simply demonstrates what I believe to be distressing levels of ignorance.

    If it were a matter of a single athlete falling out, I wouldn't feel nearly as angry: Sometimes you get people who are more susceptible to environmental factors than others, and they often look perfectly healthy. It's when you've got over a dozen athletes treated and three admitted, that I think that the problem can be assumed to have been systemic, not simply the coach/team winning a bad health lottery.

  5. #5
    Padding Enabler Panther Squad's avatar
    Registered
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Southeastern MA
    Posts
    679

    Default

    This seems self-explanatory and really shitty. Using water as a reward is never the solution. If anything it's pretty basic knowledge that the more water THE BETTER, especially when you're working out. Being properly hydrated helps your body recoup and build more muscle.

    This sounds like one of those awful situations where some adult thinks that suffering will 'toughen' children through needless suffering.
    comcast guy - m4m - 18 (nb)
    seem like we had that connection when we looked at each other
    you had a blue shirt on nice asss,dought you will see this but dosnt hurt to try, but id love to play with you. tell me what you where fixing, or the street name,or describe me.

  6. #6
    Padding Enabler Panther Squad's avatar
    Registered
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Southeastern MA
    Posts
    679

    Default

    This seems self-explanatory and really shitty. Using water as a reward is never the solution. If anything it's pretty basic knowledge that the more water THE BETTER, especially when you're working out. Being properly hydrated helps your body recoup and build more muscle.

    This sounds like one of those awful situations where some adult thinks that suffering will 'toughen' children through needless suffering.
    comcast guy - m4m - 18 (nb)
    seem like we had that connection when we looked at each other
    you had a blue shirt on nice asss,dought you will see this but dosnt hurt to try, but id love to play with you. tell me what you where fixing, or the street name,or describe me.

+ Reply to thread

Posting rules

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts