This first guy has a nice voice. I like him.
This first guy has a nice voice. I like him.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
This chick's phrasing is killing me, but her voice is lovely.
What the hell does she have on?(I try to listen without watching firts)
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
#3 can really sing. Tonight isn't bad so far. Except for his throat clearing warbling thing.
I take it back = he's REALLY getting on my damn nerves trying to get gruff since someone online called him a name.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
I didn't like yodel girl.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
I love this guy. He's not overdoing it. Hey There Delilah is a great song choice for his voice. I hope he makes it through.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
Kristen can sing. Great job although she looks like a milkmaid.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
This guy is singing Meatloaf and he sounds like Cher on the uptempo bits. He does have a good voice.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
Started out well and then hit that flat note.
I don't like her phrasing - or over the top delivery.
She can really sing but she wasted her chance IMO.
I soooo disagree with Paula.
And Simon.
And Randy.
And the other chica.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
Meh.
He missed quite a few notes.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
No Kendell, no!
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
First guy was okay. A little bland, but okay.
Second girl was a real snoozer.
Alex is cute dorky, he's getting ready to sing.
Urk. Alex is not doing anything for me.
[spoiler:17hwb2hz]I love Jorge. He's got my vote.[/spoiler:17hwb2hz]
I'm glad to see you, Julie.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
ABBA! I love ABBA, though this isn't one of my favorites of theirs.
Urk. Why is she warbling in that weird way?
Hey, babycakes. Thanks for starting this thread. As you can tell, I recorded it and am playing it back now.Originally posted by jali
Spoiler (mouseover to read):
Bad Mary J. Blige. Wrong song. Sucky arrangement.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
Ariana really is cute as a button.
Ju'not! I'm looking forward to him.
I call her yodel-girl.Originally posted by Julie
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
I would like Ju'not to sing me to sleep. I like that a lot.
That's giving her too much credit. Yodeling is hard. What she was doing was just wrong!Originally posted by jali
Wasn't that a sweet version of a sweet song? I didn't remember him, but I'm glad he's here.Originally posted by Julie
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
I think he sang that in Hollywood, but I wasn't sure.Originally posted by jali
Oh, Tracy Chapman is probably not a good choice. She's one of my favorites, but she's so much about attitude and mood rather than notes.
She can sing but I'm not really excited. Don't yell wooo!
NOOOOOOOOOO, not Meat Loaf!
Nathaniel made me feel like I was trapped in an aerobics video.
Felicia, was meh. Not horrible, but meh.
Ooh, Bruce Hornsby!
There were moments where I thought Scott could sing, but then it'd go off the rails.
Sad. I love me some Bruce Hornsby.
Hrmm. The judges are way off on this one.
I hate country music. Well, modern country music.
And bubble skirts.
And singers who try to sing way below their range. Ow. Ow. Ow.
Jorge is kind of a hottie, isn't he?
Two Elton John songs, huh?
Much better than the other EJ song! That was pretty good.
I've liked three guys and no girls tonight. But then, I think that's been the way so far this season except for the chickie the first week.
Oh, there's another girl. I forgot about her.
Lil is cute as a button. I wanted to like that more than I did.
I'm sick in bed and only flipped away from MSNBC when Rachel Maddow was over, which means I missed the first half. Based on the second half, I'm not too unhappy about that. The two blonde chicks could be clones.
AKA Shayna from SD
Jorge actually kicked that song's ass!
AKA Shayna from SD
I find Jorge kind of funny looking and off-putting. He has a beautiful voice, but I didn't find any magic in his performance, though.Originally posted by Julie
My favourite tonight was Ju'not. Kids these days, after growing up on a steady diet of Mariah Carey, Celine Dion and Christina Aguilera, have no touch at all - he did a nice job on not oversinging that.
I've loved Alex Wagner-Trugman from day one when he lipped off to Simon, but he shot himself in the foot tonight. He can sing much better than he showed tonight.
I just hope that the 3 who make it through tonight are the ones who shop the best.
Really?Originally posted by featherlou
Well, my tastes tend toward the unpopular, so you're probably right.
I think Jorge will be great doing emotional songs - something like DLG's Huey. I like him.
My favorite is Ju'not and second is Jorge tonight. The girls really irritated me. The old looking blond girl wearing the mom-like dress can sing, but she's snarky/sexy and she got on my nerves.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
Oh, I remembered what I wanted to say - in the interests of people in different time zones and watching from tape, can we call people things a little bit more specific than, "The girl that's singing now"?
I eagerly await tonight's additions to the thread so I can see who gets to stay without wading through the dreck of the hour long results show.
Sure can.Originally posted by featherlou
It was just me, talking to myself for a while, but I'll be sure to be more descriptive.
Yodel-girl is a good descriptive name.
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
My guesses - Ju'Not, Lil Rounds, and Von Smith.
My guesses: Jorge, Blind Guy & Lil Rounds
I hope my 2 guys make it.
I wont spoiler the first pick.
C'mon Ju'not and Jorge. j is a great letter!
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo oooooo!
She's back.
[spoiler:39tcz83j]Tatiana.[/spoiler:39tcz83j]
They weren't singing....they were just honking.
Glee 2009
I don't wanna watch the show. Someone gimme the whole set o'spoilers?
The top 3 vote-getters were Lil, Scott & Jorge.
There are 8 coming back tomorrow night for another round of singing and voting. The judges' choices were:
Von Smith
Jasmine Murray
Rickey Braddy
Megan Corkrey
Tatiana Del Toro
Matt Giraud
Jesse Langseth and
Anoop
I'm very glad that Jorge made it through. And I think the picks for the Wild Card show are mostly the right choices, though I would have really, really liked to see Nick go through, but with Simon hating his guts, that was never going to happen. I even like Tatiana!
Interesting how they staged the group sing around Scott's disability. I wonder how they'll approach it in future shows, depending on how far he makes it.
AKA Shayna from SD
Aww, I'm very disappointed. I loved Ju'Not's performance and Jorge's, while technically perfect, left me cold.
Although it wasn't a completely out-of-this-world guess, I was right!
Now's the time to bring back Anoop, Tatiana (just for the good singing and trainwreck factor) and Ricky Braddy (seems like a nice enough kid w/a good voice).
I hope to hell they don't bring back Megan Corkrey or Jasmine Murray. If Vapid Kara says one more time, "Mmmm, yeah... you're very commercial!" I might break my TV.
Is Jesse the girl who sang "Bette Davis Eyes"? If so, I like her voice the most of any of the women, I think.
:: Checks notes ::Originally posted by Julie
Yep. Also according to my notes, I thought she was OK and the judges thought she was meh. (We have a little AI predictions contest where I work, so I like to keep track of such things.) I'm glad she's back for the Wild Card. The judges must have liked her earlier performances better than her Top 36 perf.
Interesting that only one is from Group 3 (C?), since I thought this week's show was the best of the 3 Top 36 shows. Anyone care to make predictions? I think my personal favorite of these eight is Von, but I predict he doesn't make the cut. Top 12 already has 6 guys, so I assume they'll take at least 2 ladies tonight. I predict Megan (sang "Put Your Records On" in semifinals), Tatiana ("Saving All My Love For You"), and Anoop ("Angel Of Mine").Originally posted by Jill
Tough call without hearing them all sing again. It hasn't started here on the left coast yet. Is anyone here watching and/or voting tonight?
AKA Shayna from SD
Those who made it through...
[spoiler:1ol17c51]Anoop, Megan Corkrey & Jasmine Murray -- Tatiana sang "Saving All My Love For You" again and had another meltdown. I couldn't even watch the whole thing.[/spoiler:1ol17c51]
Without reading the spoiler, and not being at the end of the show yet, I'm utterly sick thinking they're going to put that twit Megan through. I couldn't believe when Simon called her relevant, then compared someone else to Taylor Hicks. That chick is spastic and her horrible moves with the flapping arms and swinging hips makes me want to smack her. Not to mention that Katharine McPhee kicked that song's ass season before last and this kid was horrible.
AKA Shayna from SD
Oh good lord, I was right. Ugh. And blech.
AKA Shayna from SD