+ Reply to Article
Results 1 to 14 of 14

Article: Why I hate TV Tropes

  1. Why I hate TV Tropes

    13 Comments by Peeta Mellark Published on 07 Jan 2011 12:33 PM
    A new blog entry has been added:

    Why I hate TV Tropes

    Well, maybe "hate" is unfair. Or perhaps "TV Tropes" is, when the site isn't really the object of my wrath. If you're unfamiliar with it, TVTropes.org is a wiki where people can enter the "tropes" they've seen in movies, TV shows, comics, webcomics, books, operas, or in fevered dreams. And what is a trope? A convention, idea or device often used by writers. But--the front page assures you--they do not want clichés.
    Right off the bat you may see the problem, as commonly used conventions, ideas and devices are at best clichés about to happen and at worst, well, clichéd.

  2. Total Comments 13

    Comments

  3. #2
    Prehistoric Bitchslapper Sarahfeena's avatar
    Registered
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Chicagoland
    Posts
    5,889

    Default

    I don't know if I can go so far as to say I hate TV Tropes, but I must confess I don't really get it. First of all, I don't really understand the difference between a trope and a cliche. At the very least, I think one is a subset of the other.

    Secondly, I agree with you that the concept of defining and categorizing them seems weird to me. I think that one of the reasons TV has become such a huge part of our culture is that it was a quick way to create a common culture for a large, diverse country like the US. But part of the fun of that is that whatever references we all understand are just that...understanding amongst ourselves. We makes jokes about the "nosy next door neighbor" and we all know exactly the kind of character we're talking about. No one has to go look it up in a dictionary and see Gladys Kravitz's picture to understand. Or there's a plot where someone lies about knowing a celebrity, and a joke will be make about Bobby Brady and his dear family friend Joe Namath, and we'll all chuckle, cause we get it. It's not important or necessary to list every known example, it's just a touchpoint, and we laugh and tacitly acknowledge that we all know the cliche (yes, I said it), and we move on. It's not academia, it's television.

  4. #3
    Elen síla lumenn' omentielvo What Exit?'s avatar
    Registered
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Central NJ (near Bree)
    Posts
    9,809

    Default

    On the other side. TV Tropes is a fun site to surf around on. Mindless fun. It is often useful for a quick reference. More humorous than "the other wiki" as they call it. Actually is some ways it is like a specialized annex to the Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy. It is also mostly harmless.

  5. #4
    Global Moderator AllWalker's avatar
    Registered
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Antipodea
    Posts
    1,479

    Default

    "Mostly harmless"? Are you insane? I once lost eight hours of my life to that site in one sitting.

    I like the concept of the site. For one thing, looking up a show like Dr Who shows just how much stuff they actually touch on over the years, and allows you to draw similarities. And some of the catagories are really, really fun. But I also like to have a reference for all sorts of tropes and cliches because one of the things I love in fiction is a beautifully inverted trope.

    And yes, some people will blindly stick labels to everything they see and hear. But if someone gives you the definition of each key word in a story you are telling, that isn't the fault of the dictionaries. Like everything else, it is a great resource that isn't always properly used. Welcome to the internet.
    Something tells me we haven't seen the last of foreshadowing.

  6. #5
    The Queen Zuul's avatar
    Registered
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Wisconsin
    Posts
    9,884

    Default

    Quote Originally posted by AllWalker View post
    But if someone gives you the definition of each key word in a story you are telling, that isn't the fault of the dictionaries. Like everything else, it is a great resource that isn't always properly used. Welcome to the internet.
    Yeah, I agree with this. It's a fun site and I've spent some time exploring all of the tropes listed for shows I like, and then reading about other things that use the same tropes, and then looking up tropes that are connected to those ones, etc. But geeks on the internet can latch onto anything with obsessive, scary tenacity. It's definitely more an internet geek thing than a TV Tropes thing.

    Sarah, a trope can be a cliche, but not every trope is one. A trope is simply something that reoccurs throughout a genre. When it's used too much it becomes a cliche, but a lot of tropes exist at a lower level. They're recognizable, but not so overdone as to pass into the cliche zone. Affably evil villains are a good example of this. They're common and most people can think of a few examples of it, but a bad guy who is also polite and friendly isn't really a cliche.
    So now they are just dirt-covered English people in fur pelts with credit cards.

  7. #6
    Administrator CatInASuit's avatar
    Registered
    Feb 2009
    Location
    Coulsdon Cat Basket
    Posts
    10,340

    Default

    The only problem with TV Tropes is when they have to positively, absolutely identify every last trope in show without backing off and leaving it to the major tropes. There are enough examples of each trope, they don't need to go into overload.

    My favourite trope is still the Thirty Xanatos Pileup though.
    In the land of the blind, the one-arm man is king.

  8. #7
    Porosity Caster parzival's avatar
    Registered
    Mar 2009
    Location
    West Coast, most likely
    Posts
    502

    Default

    I think the thing I like the least about TV Tropes is when people warn me about a link. Really, it's okay. I'm not going to get lost at that site. It's just not that insightful or interesting. I think the furthest I've ever gone is about two clicks deep. And that was only to figure out what the name refers to.
    Figuring out what the trope names mean is, to me, about the only interesting thing about the site, and yet even that isn't done well. Often you have to read through a lengthy discourse on the trope to figure out the reference, which may not even be explained. Even when it is, it's usually an off-hand sentence that doesn't really explain anything unless you're familiar with the material.
    That's a problem that runs throughout the site - the majority of the references, notes, etc. only make sense if you already know the material. So I gain nothing by comparing one "trope" to another unless I'm intimate with the details of both sources. For those sources I know, the mere mentioning of the trope doesn't yield anything of value to me. As already said, this isn't useful criticism, it's just a catalog.
    Yet, as a catalog, it's not that great either. It's poorly structured - while some tropes are well-defined as sub-tropes of others, all pages on the site appear the same. This leads to confusion over where to place an item. This is only made worse by the desire of some to split the tropes to ever smaller distinctions, to the point that they may only apply to a single case or even not at all. It seems that nearly every Examples section is half full of "subversions" and "inversions" and arguments that the trope is being wrongly applied.
    While some of those could eventually be fixed, it's perhaps a good indicator of why an unstructured Wiki is not a good choice for a project like this - it will take quite a while before a meaningful catalog appears from the chaos. Even then, I still don't see why I'd want to spend time looking at it.

  9. #8
    Unregistered
    Guest

    Default

    The website itself tends to have some interesting and funny things, but most of the people on there aren't very bright. Although it's not really particularly worse than most of the other places on the web.

  10. #9
    Unregistered
    Guest

    Default Thread Review

    The thing I dislike about Tv Tropes is that any random person can sign up and mess with things. I noticed on some pages of my favorite shows that people were posting tropes based on their opinions on not on the show's contents. It's kind of like how people can change anything on wikipedia but ten times worse.

  11. #10
    Hombom
    Guest

    Default Fear For Your Lives

    On the 12th of April 2011 I got kicked out the site for saying all women's groups hate men. They do all hate men and they are out to castrate, imprison and starve us no matter what we do because they all believe being born male automatically makes you the oppressor.

  12. #11
    Unregistered
    Guest

    Default

    Quote Originally posted by Hombom View post
    On the 12th of April 2011 I got kicked out the site for saying all women's groups hate men. They do all hate men and they are out to castrate, imprison and starve us no matter what we do because they all believe being born male automatically makes you the oppressor.
    Are you serious? Just shut up.

  13. #12
    Unregistered
    Guest

    Default Actually...

    Quote Originally posted by Hombom View post
    On the 12th of April 2011 I got kicked out the site for saying all women's groups hate men. They do all hate men and they are out to castrate, imprison and starve us no matter what we do because they all believe being born male automatically makes you the oppressor.
    They kicked you out because you're the kind of Troper that makes this blogger hate the site. (I'm a Troper myself, and I get frustrated with people who make the site look bad, like you. No big loss.

  14. #13
    Unregistered
    Guest

    Default

    Quote Originally posted by Hombom View post
    On the 12th of April 2011 I got kicked out the site for saying all women's groups hate men. They do all hate men and they are out to castrate, imprison and starve us no matter what we do because they all believe being born male automatically makes you the oppressor.
    go to another forum to argue about that. we don't want you anymore.

  15. #14
    Unregistered
    Guest

    Default A tropes is not necessarily a cliche

    Quote Originally posted by Sarahfeena View post
    I don't know if I can go so far as to say I hate TV Tropes, but I must confess I don't really get it. First of all, I don't really understand the difference between a trope and a cliche. At the very least, I think one is a subset of the other.
    A cliche is necessarily a subset of a trope. It's an overused trope to be specific. But a trope need not be a cliche. For example, the trope "Springtime for Hitler" is about someone puts all their efforts into failing at a task, since it is advantageous to them, but somehow they end up succeeding in the task, which in itself is failure. Now, I personally have rarely come across this trope in the works I've seen (limited experience on my end, no doubt) and I can't call this a cliche. It is, however, a trope that has been used in multiple works.

    As for the purpose of the tv tropes site...I've found exactly one so far. Say you vaguely remember a show from the past. You don't remember the names of the show or of any of its characters. But you remember a plot element, some detail that stuck out. Well, if you're a troper and know the name of that plot element, just go to its page and find the example. Though, "Yahoo! Answers" or the like might give you better results.

+ Reply to Article

Posting rules

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts